The following are good sources for religious gifts:

Religious Gifts Warehouse, click here.

Autom is another good website, click here.

Sacred Heart Gifts and Apparel, click here.
They are located at 926 Route 6 in Mahopac, NY. 845-621-7777

If you prefer hands-on locally, there is a retail store in Elmsford with a nice selection:
G. Siccardi & Family
125 East Main Street
Elmsford, NY 10523
914-946-4515